Comparative Analysis of Healthcare Service Quality in Public and Private Facilities in South Al Batinah Governorate, Oman
Saravanan D1*, Ashraf Albalushi TM2, Nasser Alfadhali AA3, Sloum Alabri RMT4, Khalfan Alabri SKS5, Abdallah Alzadjali SA6
DOI:10.31033/IJEMR/16.2.2026.1910
1* Dhanalakshmi Saravanan, College of Economics and Business Administration, University of Technology and Applied Sciences, Al Mussanah, Oman.
2 Talal Mohammed Ashraf Albalushi, Student, 51J2182, University of Technology and Applied Sciences, Al Mussanah, Oman.
3 Ali Abdallah Nasser Alfadhali, Student, 51J19169, University of Technology and Applied Sciences, Al Mussanah, Oman.
4 Rawan Masaaod Thunai Sloum Alabri, Student, 51S2041, University of Technology and Applied Sciences, Al Mussanah, Oman.
5 Shafa Khalfan Said Khalfan Alabri, Student, 51S2136, University of Technology and Applied Sciences, Al Mussanah, Oman.
6 Sharifa Abdulhakeem Abdallah Alzadjali, Student, 51J2134, University of Technology and Applied Sciences, Al Mussanah, Oman.
Background: Despite substantial infrastructure investment in Oman, rigorous patient-centred comparative evidence on healthcare service quality across public and private sectors at the governorate level remains limited.
Objective: To evaluate and compare perceived healthcare service quality in public and private healthcare facilities in South Al Batinah Governorate, Oman, using the SERVQUAL framework (N = 200).
Methods: A quantitative, cross-sectional survey of 200 adult patients (100 per sector) was conducted. Gap scores (Perception − Expectation) were computed across the five SERVQUAL dimensions: tangibles, reliability, responsiveness, assurance and empathy. One-sample t-tests assessed whether gap scores differed from zero within each sector. Welch’s independent-samples t-tests and two-way ANOVA examined sectoral and dimensional effects.
Results: Public hospital patients reported significant negative gap scores across all five dimensions: Tangibles (M = −0.258, p = .008), Reliability (M = −0.367, p < .001), Responsiveness (M = −0.635, p < .001), Assurance (M = −0.220, p = .027) and Empathy (M = −0.255, p = .024). Private hospital patients showed significant negative gaps only in Tangibles (M = −0.287, p < .001); gaps in Reliability, Responsiveness, Assurance and Empathy were non-significant, indicating expectations are broadly met in service-delivery processes. Welch’s t-tests confirmed significant public–private differences in Reliability (t(197.4) = −2.790, p = .006, d = 0.395) and Responsiveness (t(194.8) = −3.593, p < .001, d = 0.508). Two-way ANOVA confirmed a significant main effect for sector (F(1, 990) = 19.123, p < .001, η² = .019) and dimension (F(4, 990) = 2.462, p = .044, η² = .010).
Conclusion: Private facilities substantially outperform public facilities in Reliability and Responsiveness — the two dimensions most strongly linked to patient satisfaction. The service quality gap is a process gap, not a facilities gap. Public providers in South Al Batinah must urgently prioritise process-level reforms aligned with Oman Vision 2040.
Keywords: SERVQUAL, Healthcare Service Quality, Patient Satisfaction, Public vs. Private Hospitals, South Al Batinah, Gap Analysis, Oman Vision 2040
| Corresponding Author | How to Cite this Article | To Browse |
|---|---|---|
| , College of Economics and Business Administration, University of Technology and Applied Sciences, Al Mussanah, Oman. Email: |
Saravanan D, Ashraf Albalushi TM, Nasser Alfadhali AA, Sloum Alabri RMT, Khalfan Alabri SKS, Abdallah Alzadjali SA, Comparative Analysis of Healthcare Service Quality in Public and Private Facilities in South Al Batinah Governorate, Oman. Int J Engg Mgmt Res. 2026;16(2):148-154. Available From https://ijemr.vandanapublications.com/index.php/j/article/view/1910 |


©